Your Tactical Training Scenario: Naked Man Attacks the Family Dog

Imagine this scenario…

It’s five a.m. and you hear a commotion outside your house. You go outside to see what’s happening and you see a completely naked man trying to choke your dog to death. What would you do?

The homeowner in this instance shot the man in the leg and held him for police. Read more about it by clicking on the link below:

Homeowner shoots naked intruder found choking dog, police say

Was the shooting justified? Would you shoot to protect your pet?

The police detective acting as the spokesperson in this incident says “it appears to be a justified shooting.” Make sure you read closely to understand why it was a justified shooting. It wasn’t because the homeowner was legally protecting his pet.

In most states, it is illegal to use deadly force (force that is likely to cause serious injury or death) to protect property. No matter how attached you are to a loving pet, that pet is not a person under the rule of law. It’s property. You can shoot someone to protect another person. You can’t shoot someone to protect a pet.

There are exceptions. Some states allow deadly force to be used to protect property in certain situations. Check out your state’s laws if you have any doubts. Castle Doctrine laws may also protect you if you shoot someone who is attacking your pet inside your house. Again, check your state’s laws.

This shooting occurred outside the house. Why was it considered justified? Read the police officer’s statement…

…at the point that the homeowner attempted to get this individual’s attention, he immediately jumped onto the owner and started fighting with him.

If you don’t read the article closely, you might get the impression that shooting to save the dog’s life is justified. It is not. This shooting was considered justified because the naked man attacked the homeowner. The homeowner shot to protect HIMSELF, not the dog. There’s a big difference.

I realize that many of you consider your pets “part of the family”. I also realize that you may consider the life of your pet more important than the life of a criminal who attacks it. I have a dog too. I truly understand. But the law doesn’t care. Pets are property in most states. Understand this concept and don’t risk going to jail for an unjustified shooting.

If you are a pet owner, your homework assignment is to think about this scenario. What would you do in the event that someone attacks your pet? What about if another animal attacks your pet?

Physical force (non deadly) is allowable under most states’ laws. Are you physically skilled enough to defend your animal? If not, pepper spray or an impact weapon might make a better choice. Pepper spray works against most dogs. I carry it without fail whenever I walk my mutt. I’m less worried about being attacked myself (especially while walking my scarred-up 75-pound rescue American Bulldog), but I worry about my dog being attacked by another pet. A quick blast of pepper spray will usually solve the problem with minimal chance of harm to either animal.

I’ve responded to two different calls in my police career about dogs attacking people. In both cases I arrived quickly enough to see the attack taking place. In both cases, I drew my collapsible baton and started swinging. Both attacking dogs ran off and I was then able to aid the victim. In my admittedly small number of experiences, I’ve found the baton quite effective. A nice cane or walking stick would be an alternative if collapsible batons are illegal to carry in your state. Either would also be effective (and likely legal) against a human attacker who tries to harm your animal.

Greg Ellifritz is the full time firearms and defensive tactics training officer for a central Ohio police department. He holds instructor or master instructor certifications in more than 75 different weapon systems, defensive tactics programs and police specialty areas. Greg has a master's degree in Public Policy and Management and is an instructor for both the Ohio Peace Officer's Training Academy and the Tactical Defense Institute.

For more information or to contact Greg, visit his training site at Active Response Training.